Thursday, January 20, 2011

Kids of Kabul


Just about every day, I walk down the street from my camp to the Ministry of Defense, which is the Afghan equivalent of the Pentagon.  Back home, the Pentagon is one of the most expensive neighborhoods in the country.  Here, the MoD headquarters building is in one of the nicer parts of Kabul (and certainly one of the safest, as it’s surrounded by tall concrete walls and razor wire) but the realities of Afghanistan’s long history of war and suffering abounds.  The saddest part are the kids.

They wait for us on just the other side of our camp’s walls.  There is usually a dozen or so of them, each hawking some trinket—scarves, handmade bead bracelets, ID card holders.  One boy—not more than 5 years old—is out there every Friday, trying to sell pictures he drew with crayons.  He’s always smiling and once in a while he’ll do a little dance in his sandals.  The kids are dirty, their hands so chapped from the cold air that they bleed.  Some of the kids wear sandals without socks; their feet are as dry as the hills that surround Kabul.  They’re dirty, their colorful and mismatched clothes stained and covered in the omnipresent dust of Afghanistan.  When it’s really cold, they huddle around small fires they make out of trash.  Some of the boys who don’t have trinkets to sell crowd us and demand to be our body guards.  They’re not older than 10.  We walk past the Spanish embassy and turn down the road that runs parallel to President Karzai’s palace walls, and they give us fist bumps.

Another boy, probably about 12, sells ID card holders.  Only he kept calling them “purses.”  One of the sergeants in my office and I worked with him for weeks, trying to get him to say “ID card holder”—explaining to him that the male U.S. soldiers don’t want to buy a purse.  He finally got it right and now every time I see him, he yells “ID card holder!”  He told me the other day he was hungry and that his brother is sick.

UNESCO recently announced that the biggest health problem facing Afghanistan is mental illness—not cholera, malaria, or even starvation, all of which are serious problems here.  It’s hard to fathom, but this country has been at war for over 30 years.  Kabul essentially was razed to the ground in the 1980s, as the mujahedeen fought the Soviets and then each other.  The Taliban swept through and forced people like my interpreter, who was then just a boy, to wear a turban, go to Islamic school, and live in fear.  On the way to MoD, we pass the spot where the former president of Afghanistan was hung by the Taliban—and we walk down the same streets where they dragged his body.  And while Kabul is relatively safe, there are a few bombings each month—delivered by things as seemingly innocuous as bicycles.
Looking into the deep brown eyes of the children outside our walls, it’s easy to see what UNESCO means.  I admit that I don’t know any of these kids’ stories.  I don’t know for sure if they suffer from the residual effects of living in a violent place.  All I know is that when I ask why they aren’t in school, they tell me that they have to work, that they’re hungry, do I want to buy a scarf? 

As my family and I prepare to welcome another child into the world, every day I look at these kids of Kabul and wonder about how different life could be.  And I thank God that my kids never had to ask what that boom was, or had to try to sell their crayon drawings, or had to build a fire out of trash.  I hope that someday those same kids outside our walls can say the same thing about their children.

Friday, January 14, 2011

The Stupid Universe Strikes Back ... Four Years After I Stupidly Offended It



As an expert in offending the universe, take it from me—when it’s time for payback, the universe is mean.

A little over four years ago, I found myself in Montgomery, Alabama.  That fact alone is not why I’m in the universe’s debt—hell, if anything, it should be the other way around.  No, my date with fate stems from an experience I had at Officer Training School in the aforementioned Montgomery, Alabama.  Our class was divided into six “flights” made up of about a dozen students.  The people in my flight were obviously smart, because they nominated me to be the flight’s candidate for the class top graduate or homecoming queen or some other award that, clearly, was based on a combination of looks and popularity.  The nominees from the six flights had to endure an interview by a board of cantankerous majors and lieutenant colonels who surely were wondering why their careers had gone so badly that they were interviewing dweeby lieutenants for a pointless award. 

This is the guy who made the world's
greatest trophy.  My trophy.
Of course, I didn’t think it was pointless at the time.  In fact, I wanted to win that thing, and not just because there were rumors that the trophy was one of those wooden ships inside a bottle.  Or maybe it was a bronzed eagle head.  The rumors were a little vague.  Anyway, the trophy notwithstanding, I also wanted to win the award because (1) I am competitive, stemming from a deep-rooted insecurity about the size of my Adam’s apple and (2) I wanted to impress my first boss.  I imagined placing that ship-in-a-bottle or bronzed eagle’s head on my desk as my boss whispered to my awe-struck co-workers, “Wow, he was the OTS homecoming queen!  And that ship-in-a-bottle really compliments his Adam’s apple, don’t you think?”  So almost needless to say, I was determined to win … and I knew the key would be acing the interview.

I assumed the interview would be a cake walk for an accomplished attorney like myself.  I mean, good grief, I had argued a case in Ohio appellate court, charmed an Air Force colonel into recommending me for a commission despite having a felony murder conviction on my record, and made nerds from Stanford cry at the National Moot Court national championships.  Charming three or four field grade officers sitting on an awards board would almost be too easy.  I even thought about wearing Groucho glasses and a fake moustache just to even the playing field, but I figured my gesture would be misinterpreted as mocking what was a solemn award.  So instead, I prepped for the interview like I was about to argue before the Supreme Court.  My instructor even worked with me on my salute, which, by the time of the interview was so perfect, so manly that I later would become the model for those “The Few, the Proud, the Marines” commercials.

On the day of the interview, I made sure my hair and uniform looked spiffier than Tom Cruise in A Few Good Men.  I went over my reporting instructions and a couple of canned responses to some questions I was sure I’d be asked.  When it was my turn to be interviewed, I knocked on the door, ran through my reporting statements with ease, and took my seat.  I don’t remember the first few questions, but I know I was killing ’em.  The people who were there told me later that I was so smooth that I made Obama sound like George W. Bush.

Then they asked The Question.  You’re a commander, one particularly crabby major on the panel said, and your entire unit is deploying.  An airman in your unit is married, and his wife is going to give birth to their first child during the deployment.  He’s upset.  What do you do?

“Run!” should have been the first thing that came to my mind, or even “Submit your separation papers dummy!”  But by the time I was being interviewed, I had sat through nearly five weeks of straight-up brainwashing.  I mean, I was ready to put on some black sneakers, climb in my bunk bed, and go and see the aliens.  I couldn’t get the Kool-Aid smile off my face.  By the end of OTS, I was ready to volunteer for five-year deployments, court-martial my subordinates for getting their hair cut during normal duty hours, and get the lyrics to the Air Force song tattooed on my butt (the placement of which would ensure compliance with AFI 36-2903).  So I stupidly said the following, and unfortunately I’m not making this up:

“Well, I’d tell him that we all signed up to be in the Air Force, we’re all volunteers, and we knew it was a possibility we’d have the opportunity to serve our great country against her enemies.  I’d tell him that I can relate to how he feels, because I have three children and being there when they were born were three of the happiest moments of my life, and boy, it would be tough to miss out on that.  But we did sign up for this.”

I’m going to be totally honest with you—even I felt like punching myself in the neck as soon as I said this.  I still feel like punching myself in the neck four years later.  But hey, I told them what I thought they wanted to hear and, damn it, if that was going to get me that ship-in-a-bottle, I could always punch myself in the neck later. 

Only I didn’t win the award.  In fact, in announcing the winner, the board president specifically noted that Lt Eberle hadn’t just told the board what one might think they wanted to hear.  I felt that particular comment was aimed directly at me, at which point I hid my Adam’s apple in shame.  I also commented to a classmate that, clearly, too much emphasis was placed on a stupid interview. 
Eh, it was an ugly trophy anyway.
As Lt Eberle went on the stage to collect her bronzed eagle’s head (I was relieved to see that it was not a ship-in-a-bottle and that it was a particularly ugly bronzed eagle’s head, which would not have gone on my fireplace mantel anyway), I figured that was it.  That the universe had extracted a little payback for my shameless pandering.  That my inability to suggest a more humane approach, like trying to ensure my Airman had access to Skype or even a satellite phone, resulted in an embarrassing loss, all because I decided to regurgitate a bunch of patriotic hooey instead of actually use my brain.

Turns out, the universe was just getting started.  It also turns out that I’m the Airman who is going to miss out on a child’s birth.  Any day now, I will receive an email from my very pregnant wife, informing me she has gone into labor.  I will then obsessively check my email for the news that I’m the father of a healthy, baby girl.  If everything works out, I’ll be able to Skype with my new daughter shortly after she comes into the world.  At the very least, I’ll have a satellite phone handy.

And if anyone tells me that hey, we signed up for this, I will definitely punch him in the neck.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

JAG Graduation -- Afghan Style


"I WILL SERVE AFGHANISTAN!!! 
well, at least until it is no longer politically expedient
for me to do so ... shhhhh!"
 Today there are 31 new Afghan JAGs.  There were supposed to be 33 but two of them wisely went AWOL midway through their five-week basic legal officer training course.  And since none of these guys have been paid for months -- and since most of them just found out that they're being assigned to some of the biggest hellholes on the planet -- and oh yeah, they were told today that you'd better be there in two days damnit and so what if you haven't seen your family for months you whiney babies -- we've set the over-under on the number of these dudes who will actually report to their assignments on Saturday at 12.  Judging by how at least a dozen of them refused to participate in the post-graduation group photo and instead stomped off, I'm taking the under.  The nice thing for them is that every March, President Karzai issues an AWOL amnesty decree.  Loosely translated, the decree reads: "Hey, we know we gave you rotten food and flea-ridden blankets and sent you to roll around on land mines and paid you in pistachios, so really, we don't blame you for going AWOL -- if you just come back within a couple of weeks, we'll pretend you never left!  Oh, and be sure to pick up a handful of pistachios on your way to setting off the land mines -- thanks!"  But hey, let's dwell on all that after the weekend, when our intrepid JAGs decide maybe being a goat farmer isn't too bad after all.  Today is all about progress and the rule of law and holding up paper certificates over your head and screaming, "I WILL SERVE AFGHANISTAN!"

Watch out Taliban!
That's what they do here, you know.  They shake hands with the mullah generals -- the same guys they curse under their breath -- take the certificate, and then hold it over their head while loudly pledging their allegiance to this nebulous concept called "Afghanistan."  And these dudes love certificates -- they'll frame pieces of paper that show they passed information assurance training.  (Note: this isn't totally true, since there is no such thing as information assurance in Afghanistan ... but if there were, they would totally frame the certificates and promise to die for their country while not looking at unauthorized websites.)  The graduation ceremony was held at the Kabul Military Training Center, which is the epicenter of all Afghan National Army training.  It's on the outskirts of Kabul, spread out on the base of treeless mountains that look like something out of southern Nevada, but only if southern Nevada had slightly fewer dudes with turbans and AK-47s roaming around them.  There were approximately 1,000 Afghan army soldiers graduating from various courses, so as we walked to the auditorium where the JAG graduation was being held, we were treated to troops goose-stepping around a vast concrete parade ground where a band of kazoos and drums played.  (Note: I'm not sure the band was actually playing kazoos, but it sure sounded like it and it sure sounded awesome.)  (Another note: It's a little-known fact that goose-stepping intimidates the Taliban.  Those buggers get horrified when they see the Afghan Army goose-stepping their way to the battlefield.)


"If you come back, we promise to
pay you this time!"
 The auditorium where the graduation was held is by far the nicest building I've seen in Afghanistan.  Sure, it looked like the typical piece of crap building from the outside that I've grown accustomed to in Kabul, but the inside was stunning -- thanks America!  There were marble floors, plush stadium-style seats, lights that were actually turned on, intricately carved wood paneling, and a lobby that was set up like those massive living rooms from mobster movies (of course, this assumes mobsters have living rooms where 20 electrical cords are plugged into the same outlet and with no heating whatsoever).  Given the plush surroundings and the fact that we had our assault rifles, some people took advantage of the scenery to pose for some photos.  Of course, I would never do something so silly as that ... and besides, my hamster-powered Internet does not allow me to post anything on this here blog, so what would be the point? 


Stadium seating: what a concept.
They have it in Kabul, but not
Waldorf, Maryland. 
 By the way, the graduation speakers here are just as crappy as the ones back home -- you are the future, we are so proud of you, don't forget that Allah is all powerful and that practicing law is just an extension of Islam ... you know, the same old song and dance.  I can't even tell you how many times I've been bored out of my mind at some high school graduation by some dude singing the Koran.  I mean, come on already.  According to our U.S. advisors at the legal school, at least six of the graduates can't read or write -- just a minor detail, I say.  After all, I've received briefs from opposing counsel before that appeared to have been written by a 4 year old (the crayon was a dead giveaway), so our Afghan partners are in good company.  I'm not sure, but I think the guys holding up the certificates that said "Hooked on Fa-ah-onics Work-ed for Me!" were the ones who couldn't read.  It didn't matter -- they screamed "I will serve Afghanistan!" just as loud as anybody. 

Man, I love this place.

All pictures stolen from the Internet.

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Adventures with Captain Crazy

Whenever you're crammed into a few square acres with 2,000 people, you’re bound to run into some crazies.  Especially when most of those 2,000 people are Army soldiers.  And whenever you take 20-something attorneys and throw them into a couple of cramped offices, you’ve got the ingredients for a reality show.  Look, I’ve encountered some strange people in the 4-plus years I’ve been a JAG—Emily’s “Little Buddy” immediately comes to mind—but nothing compares to Captain Crazy.  This girl is a train wreck.  I’ve been a defense counsel long enough to know she’s got a personality disorder.  Seriously.  Fortunately, I don’t have to work with her much, but seeing as how she’s been fired from just about every other job in the office, she could end up in my section yet.  If that happens, I’m defecting … to the Afghan army.  After all, I’ve always wanted to wear loafers with my fatigues. 

Anyway, my first encounter with Captain Crazy was a week or so ago.  We’re helping the Afghans develop a case management system so they can keep track of the people they’ve thrown in jail.  I’m not exaggerating when I say people literally have been arrested, put in pretrial confinement, and several months later everyone is wondering who in the hell that is in Cell Block C (hint: his name is probably Mohammed and he’s probably in Cell Block C because he couldn’t afford to pay a $10 bribe).  So having a case management system, even if it's made out of papier mache, is a big deal.  Despite being a couple sandwiches short of a picnic, this particular captain is helping coordinate the development of the system.  Last week, she sent out an email to the various legal officers involved asking for feedback on the system so far.  Since the system doesn’t work for my Afghan army guys due to them using a completely different criminal code, I took the opportunity to give her a call and discuss ways we can possibly make it work.  I apparently failed to understand her request for feedback meant I was supposed to shower her with praise. 

I was quickly accused of trying to shut down the entire system, ruin the program, and basically cause World War III.  I knew I was in for a treat when my deputy, who was sitting next to me and could hear Captain Crazy screaming on the phone, almost fell out of her seat laughing.  I took a deep breath and calmly asked the captain why she was so freaking crazy accusing me of trying to “shut down the system.”  Words came out of her mouth but let’s put it this way—after the government figures out why those birds died in Arkansas, they’ll be working on the mystery of what the hell this girl was trying to say.  I told her that I was having trouble following her.  I think I may have even said, “Captain Crazy, I hear words coming out of your mouth but they are not making sense to my brain.”  Big, nonsensical words continued to spill from her lips before I finally cut her off and told her that I was simply trying to help.  She then went on a rant about how she doesn’t like it when people call her and criticize what she’s doing.  I reminded Captain Crazy that she had sent an email asking for feedback and that I wasn’t criticizing her or “her” system, nor did I appreciate being accused of clubbing baby seals (this may have been one of the allegations she levied against me; she’s that crazy).  Thirty minutes later, I finally got her to understand that the Afghan army uses a different criminal code, which simply needs to be programmed into this system.  “Oh,” she said.  “Thanks.”  If I were a betting man, I’d say there’s a 1,000 percent chance poor Mohammed will be sitting in that cell on C Block for a long while.

My second run-in with Captain Crazy occurred today.  Only this time it was in person.  In a meeting with some very important people.  And we were the only two people from our office at the meeting with these very important people—very important people who are trying to figure out what is messed up with a particular part of Afghanistan for which our office may or may not be responsible.  Captain Crazy normally attends this particular meeting (although the focus of the meeting is normally blaming Afghans for serious stuff, in which case I suppose her crazy leaps of logic are an asset).  Given the nature of the meeting, Captain Crazy apparently was told by the staff judge advocate to not say anything.  The SJA obviously knows this girl.  Anyway, the SJA wanted me to attend because the meeting involved some issues I've been working on . . . when I haven’t been busy clubbing baby seals.  So the SJA told me to go and answer any questions these important people may have. 


So these very important people started asking questions and I started answering them.  Somewhat surprisingly—especially given the amount of rank present in the room—the conversation became a fairly free-flowing discourse.  Everything was going swimmingly.  I was swatting away their questions like the bats I killed in our Ohio house--thwack!  thwack!  thwack!  I was getting ready for my parade, for the awarding of my medal , for all the backslaps and handshakes and awkward questions of whether I was going to run for president.  Until Captain Crazy opened her mouth.  First, she snapped at a colonel and told him that we weren’t authorized to be talking about the subject matter.  She failed to say that she was not authorized to speak.  She also criticized the colonel for not sending her some information before the meeting so she could silently stew about it . . . since she wasn’t authorized to talk about it in the meeting anyway.  The worst of it is that her stiff arm made us look like we had something to hide.  Look, when very important people are looking at you to provide some kind of justification for why you shouldn’t be blamed for something, it usually doesn’t help to tell them that you aren’t talking.  If there’s anything I learned as a journalist it’s that “no comment” means “yup, I did it.”  Kind of like when Rick Majerus told me “no comment” when I asked him if he had shown his wiener to his basketball players.  True story. 

Anyway, Captain Crazy didn’t stop there.  She proceeded to sit in the meeting with a scowl on her face.  Then she verbally abused one of the meeting participants, a senior-level civilian.  This particular civilian appeared to be a lovely, calm and competent woman.  The woman said something about the Afghan police’s capability to do something.  I don’t remember exactly what that capability was, since I was getting stupider and stupider the longer I was in Captain Crazy’s negative energy field.  I still haven’t totally recovered.  Anyway, Captain Crazy is an expert on Afghan police because she has been working with them for two whole months.  Now mind you, I don’t think she’s ever met an Afghan police officer in her life, but that’s a minor detail.  So being the expert she is, Captain Crazy naturally disagreed with the woman.  The woman in turn explained that, based on her THREE AND A HALF YEARS working with the police, she was fairly certain the police could do X, Y and Z.  She actually said this very calmly and professionally, without any sarcasm or malice in her voice.  Captain Crazy’s response?  “Well, you’re just a contractor.”  She said it like it was a slur.  Forget for a second that most of the contractors here are retired military, including a fair amount of retired generals—saying anybody is “just a contractor” or “just a reservist” or “just a whatever” is rude, petty and unprofessional.  The very important people at this meeting suddenly had very surprised looks on their faces.  Hell, the girl might as well as have clubbed that baby seal right there on the conference table.  And they were looking at both of us—as if I already had a mouth full of seal blubber in my mouth.  I honestly have never been so embarrassed to be wearing a military uniform as I did at that moment.  I thought about pretending to not know her, but it was too late.

The meeting went downhill from there.  I did my best to deflect and tap dance, and I managed to buy my bosses some time to respond later this week.  But don’t be surprised if you see a news conference in the not-too-distant future when some important people say “No comment” to some pretty tough questions.  And if anyone asks what Captain Crazy is doing in Cell Block C, I’ll just shrug my shoulders and lament that there’s no case management system here in Afghanistan.

Friday, December 31, 2010

Happy New Year

New Year’s Eve is the one day of the year where we can get away with reflecting on the past while simultaneously focusing on the future.  For that reason, it has always struck me as odd.  Probably the strangest part of it all, though, is this embedded belief that somehow the world will be different once that glowing ball hits the bottom of the pole in Times Square.  This belief was never more in vogue than on December 31, 1999.

Ringing in a new millennium is momentous, I suppose, particularly when it seems that’s all the media talks about for a solid year.  Then there was the whole Y2K scare.  I remember the first video images of people ringing in the new millennium, starting in Sydney, Australia.  Every hour, there was a new feed – fireworks in Bangkok, New Delhi, Jerusalem, Athens, Berlin, Paris, London, and eventually New York City – and news stories about the impending doom of our computer systems crumbling.  But what I remember most about New Year’s Eve 1999 was sitting in bed next to my sleeping wife, trying to wrap my head around the fact that I was about to be a father.

Emily was exhausted.  Being just a few days away from your due date will do that to you, I suppose.  She didn’t it make it much later than 10 p.m. before she started dozing off.  At first, she apologized, but after a half hour or so, she couldn’t fight it anymore.  I stayed up out of a sense of obligation.  The volume on our bedroom TV was barely audible, which was all the same because I never cared for Dick Clark anyway.  As the hour approached midnight, there were the obligatory interviews with overly excited weirdos wearing those “2000” eyeglasses – and all the talk was on the future.  As if a couple of ticks on a clock would mean we somehow traveled the gap between reality and some separate world where the future waited to reveal itself.

Of course, nothing would change.  The ball would drop and everyone would sing and most everyone would kiss somebody, just like they do every year.  The computers wouldn’t crash.  The world wouldn’t be any different.  Deep down, I knew it really wouldn’t be any different than any other year, any other night in the history of the earth.  We wouldn’t travel the gap between the present and the future.  It would always be the present and time’s mathematical equation would continue to compute as it always has and always will.  But I did wake up Emily.  “There’s 10 seconds to go,” I said.  She stirred awake, shifting her weight slightly.  We kissed at zero and she went back to sleep.  I turned off the TV and lied next to her.  I could feel her belly, hard and stretched thin and full of bones. 

Nine days later, the world did change.  I held my son for the first time.  My hands shook.  All that talk about the millennium being a new beginning, a new era was just nine days premature.  In that instant, as I held him, all slippery and flailing arms and legs, I realized that I’d never be the same person I’d been the second before.  In that instant, I traversed the canyon between the present and the future.  It had nothing to do with a dropping ball or Dick Clark or even the measurement of time.  It was the first day in my son’s new year.  I haven’t been the same since. 

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Smells Worse Than the Food ...


The home of our new septic tank.  Right next to the pizza joint.
  Walking around camp is an assault on the senses. Namely the sense of smell. For some reason, there's no central plumbing in Afghanistan. I suppose waging 30 years of jihad makes developing a sewer system fall down the list of priorities, but really, it's no excuse. And even though we've been here for almost 10 years now, pumping billions of dollars into building this country's infrastructure, we're still pumping out all of our poo. Including here at my camp, which I'm thinking is really just an assortment of buildings and converted shipping containers designed to hide the many septic tanks just below the surface. And trust me, they are just below the surface -- you can see the wavy stink lines rising up out of the gravel pathways.

There's only way to get stuff out of a septic tank, and over here it comes in the form of large vacuum trucks. The trucks roll around camp about three times a day. These three times just happen to coincide with meals. And naturally, the two main septic tanks just happen to be located right outside of the dining facilities. I came upon this unfortunate marriage of time, location, and sewage on my first day here. I grabbed an ice cream bar on my way out of the dining hall and, just as I was about to bite into the rich chocolate-coated vanilla goodness, I got a face blast of sewage odors. The smell was strong enough to almost taste. And it completely ruined my ice cream bar experience.

This diagram really needs to be put in use here.
Unfortunately, the ice cream bar isn't the only thing that has been ruined -- just about every breakfast, lunch, and dinner has started with an unhealthy appetizer of poo whiff. Sometimes I try to hold my breath, but just when I think the worst has passed and finally inhale, I'm greeted with an especially long lung-searing reintroduction of Eau de Sewer. I guess it could be worse -- the other day I had to relieve myself in an Afghan port-a-potty over at the Ministry of Defense and what I saw and smelled in there gave me PTSD. I'd just like to know who decided to put the septic tanks right by the dining facilities. I'm not entirely sure, but I think it was the Taliban.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Farewell to a Bad Dude

When I was a journalist, the highlight of my week consisted of just 2 or 3 seconds.  After spending days trying to track down and get a hold of the subject of my article -- usually a rumored bad actor who I needed to contact for the obligatory "no comment" -- he would finally pick up the phone or answer the knock on their office door.  I'd introduce myself and then wait for the inevitable silence that comes when a person knows he's been caught.  It would only last a few seconds before the door slammed or the phone went dead, but that silence was what I worked for. 

The other day, the Afghan Minister of Defense ordered the removal of 4 Afghan generals and over 20 colonels who had helped turn their National Military Hospital into a disease-infested nightmare where patients literally starved to death because doctors and nurses simply stopped showing up for work.  The level of care was nightmarish and some day I suppose I'll be able to share it -- for now, just Google "Afghanistan National Military Hospital" and you'll should come across some news stories that give you a small taste of what is going on there.


Shortly after my arrival here, I was assigned to advise a group of Afghan prosecutors who were looking into abuse at the hospital.  Lucky me, I got a tour.  I also got my first glimpse of the deservedly fatalistic view that corruption in this country will be rooted out sometime between never and hell freezing over.  As eager as the prosecutors were, it was hard to find any direct evidence of corruption -- after all, when you've spent 200 years ripping off the Brits, the Soviets, and the U.S., you get rather proficient at theft and deception.  One of the biggest challenges was finding an Afghan source willing to talk.  About two weeks ago, I found him.  He works at the hospital and he had seen and heard a few things.  Nothing that would hold up in court, mind you, but interesting tendrils of smoke that signaled nearby fire.  The only problem is he doesn't trust other Afghans.  Not even a little bit.  Understandably, he was too worried to meet with me at his office, so he met me on our camp.  I met with him alone (other than my translator).  I plied him with free coffee and cookies, furiously jotted down notes and pressed him on details.  I talked about his love for his country and how it was necessary for brave people like him to come forward.  He looked at me like the newbie I am and, with just one glare over the rim of his glasses, reminded me that he rather enjoyed having his head attached to his body.  I talked up the director of the Afghan Army's Criminal Investigation Division, telling my source what an honest man he was, how he was committed to prosecuting these mafias who stoop low enough to steal from dying soldiers.  I asked my source if he'd be willing to talk to CID.  He chuckled and said "No way."  I offered more coffee and cookies to no avail.  Importantly, however, I did get his permission to share his info with coalition forces -- as long as I didn't disclose his identity to his countrymen. 

I went back to my office and typed up the notes.  I made it clear that my source would not testify – and wouldn't even cooperate in an investigation.  But I detailed what I'd heard, most of which involved allegations against a general at the hospital (we'll call him General Afzal).  And let me tell you, this guy did some pretty awful stuff.  But it was all single-sourced.  Not only would it never hold up in court, but it wouldn't even qualify as good journalism.  Sure, I'd heard General Afzal's name continually, heard similar accusations against him, but I had not come across anything concrete.  All I really had were a few pages of conjecture, a lot of smoke and common sense.

Four days ago, the Afghan Minister of Defense (
MINDEF) held a meeting with all the hospital personnel in a big auditorium at NMH.  At the meeting, he announced that with the approval of President Karzai, General Afzal and others had been fired.  General Afzal was present at the meeting, at least up until the announcement was made.  I was told by one of my bosses that my notes had helped MINDEF win an argument with senior Afghan officials over whether General Afzal should stay.  It was a bittersweet feeling -- I was happy General Afzal was gone, but I did feel slightly dirty for essentially dignifying hearsay allegations.  In the end, though, trying to meet a court-worthy burden of proof in this case likely would have meant more soldiers needlessly dying at the hospital.  Waiting to build a case and hoping the Afghan military justice system would properly punish General Afzal was just too much of a risk.  He had to go.

I understand that when MINDEF announced the firing, General Afzal was completely silent for 2 or 3 seconds before storming out of the room.  I wish I had been there to see it.